Mola Ali ع Nay Hazrat Abu Bakar Say Sulah Kar li ???

AI Mode
All
Images
Videos
Shopping
Forums
Short videos
News
Maps
Web
Books
Flights
Finance
Sahih al-Bukhari Hadith 4240 (paired with 4241 in the Book of Military Expeditions / Al-Maghazi, Chapter on the Ghazwa of Khaibar) is narrated by Aisha and recounts the dispute over inheritance and leadership following the death of Prophet Muhammad.


Sunnah.com
You can read the full text on Sunnah.com.

Key Events in the Narration
Inheritance & Response: Fatima requested her share of the Prophet’s estate (including Fadak and Khaibar) from Caliph Abu Bakr, who declined, citing the Prophet’s teaching that prophets leave no inheritance and their property becomes Sadaqa (charity).


Sunnah.com
Aftermath & Ali’s Allegiance: Fatima remained estranged from Abu Bakr until her death six months later. Afterwards, Ali approached Abu Bakr, explained his initial hesitation regarding rulership out of a sense of kinship rights, and pledged public allegiance to him.


Sunnah.com
Historical & Interpretive Context
Sectarian Views: While Sunni scholarship accepts this report as authentic, some Shia readers and critics on platforms like Reddit question parts of the account—specifically the nature of Ali’s reconciliation and pledge—due to differing historical traditions.


Islam Stack Exchange
+1
Would you like to look at related narrations (such as Sahih al-Bukhari 3714 or Sahih Muslim 1759a), or explore Sunni and Shia historical perspectives on Fadak in greater detail?




Sahih al-Bukhari Hadith 4240 (paired with 4241 on Sunnah.com) translated into Roman English (Hinglish/Roman Urdu) is provided below:
Sahih al-Bukhari: Hadith 4240 (Roman Urdu / Roman English)
Hazrat Aisha (R.A) se riwayat hai:
Nabi Kareem (ﷺ) ki beti Hazrat Fatima (R.A) ne (jab Hazrat Abu Bakr khalifa bane) unke paas kisi ko bhej kar apni miras (inheritance) ka mutalba kiya—us maal mein se jo Allah ne Rasoolullah (ﷺ) ko Madina mein Fai (baghair jung ke haasil hone wala maal), Fadak, aur Khaibar ke Khumus (paanchwe hisse) mein se bacha hua ata farmaya tha.


Sunnah.com
+1
Is par Hazrat Abu Bakr (R.A) ne farmaya: “Rasoolullah (ﷺ) ne irshad farmaya tha ke ‘Hum (Ambiya) ki koi miras nahi hoti; jo kuch hum chhor kar jaate hain woh Sadaqa hai, albatta Aal-e-Muhammad (ﷺ) is maal mein se kha sakti hai.’ Allah ki qasam! Main Rasoolullah (ﷺ) ke sadaqa ki haalat mein koi tabdeeli nahi karunga, aur usay usi haalat par rakhunga jaisa ke woh Nabi (ﷺ) ke zamane mein tha, aur usi tarah kharch karunga jaise aap (ﷺ) kiya karte thay.” Chunancha Hazrat Abu Bakr (R.A) ne Hazrat Fatima (R.A) ko us mein se kuch dene se inkar kar diya.


Sunnah.com
Is baat par Hazrat Fatima (R.A) Hazrat Abu Bakr (R.A) se naraz ho gayin aur unse alag-thalag rehne lagin, aur apni wafat tak unse baat nahi ki. Aap (ﷺ) ke inteqal ke baad woh cheh (6) mahine tak zinda rahin.
Jab unka inteqal hua, to unke shauhar Hazrat Ali (R.A) ne Hazrat Abu Bakr (R.A) ko ittila diye baghair unhe raat ke waqt dafan kar diya aur khud hi unki namaz-e-janaza padhayi.


Sunnah.com
+1
Jab tak Hazrat Fatima (R.A) zinda thin, log Hazrat Ali (R.A) ki badi izzat o tawajjo karte thay, lekin unki wafat ke baad Hazrat Ali (R.A) ne logon ke rawaiye mein tabdeeli mehsoos ki. Is liye Hazrat Ali (R.A) ne Hazrat Abu Bakr (R.A) se sulah aur bai’at karne ka irada kiya—kyunki un mahinon (Nabi ﷺ ki wafat se lekar Hazrat Fatima R.A ki wafat tak) mein unhone bai’at nahi ki thi.
Hazrat Ali (R.A) ne Hazrat Abu Bakr (R.A) ko paigham bheja ke “Hamare paas aaiye, lekin aapke saath koi aur na aaye,” kyunki woh Hazrat Umar (R.A) ke aane ko pasand nahi kar rahe thay. Hazrat Umar (R.A) ne (Abu Bakr se) kaha: “Nahi, Allah ki qasam! Aap akele unke paas nahi jayenge.” Hazrat Abu Bakr (R.A) ne kaha: “Tumhara kya khayal hai ke woh mere saath kya karenge? Allah ki qasam, main unke paas zaroor jaunga.”


Sunnah.com
Chunancha Hazrat Abu Bakr (R.A) unke paas tashreef le gaye. Hazrat Ali (R.A) ne Tashahhud padha aur kaha: “Hum aapki fazilat aur jo kuch Allah ne aapko ata farmaya hai usay khoob jaante hain, aur Allah ne jo bhalai aapko di hai hum us par hasad nahi karte. Lekin aapne khilafat ke mamle mein hum se mashwara nahi kiya, aur hum samajhte thay ke Rasoolullah (ﷺ) se hamari qareebi rishtedari ki wajah se is mein hamara bhi haq hai.”


Sunnah.com
Yeh sun kar Hazrat Abu Bakr (R.A) ki aankhon se aansu beh nikle. Unhone farmaya: “Us zaat ki qasam jiske haath mein meri jaan hai, mere liye Rasoolullah (ﷺ) ke rishtedaron se sila-rehmi karna apne rishtedaron se sila-rehmi karne se zyada mehboob hai. Aur jahan tak is maal ke bare mein mere aur aapke darmiyan ikhtilaf ki baat hai, to main isay bhalai ke kaamon mein kharch karne mein koi kasar nahi chhorunga, aur jo tareeqa maine Rasoolullah (ﷺ) ko is mein ikhtiyar karte dekha hai, main usay harghiz nahi chhorunga balki usi par amal karunga.”

Is par Hazrat Ali (R.A) ne Hazrat Abu Bakr (R.A) se kaha: “Aaj dopahar (Zuhr) mein aapke haath par bai’at karne ka waada hai.”


Sunnah.com
Phir jab Hazrat Abu Bakr (R.A) ne Zuhr ki namaz padh li, to mimbar par tashreef le gaye, Tashahhud padha aur Hazrat Ali (R.A) ka waqia aur bai’at mein takheer ki wajah bayan ki aur unka uzr qubool kiya. Phir Hazrat Ali (R.A) khade hue, Allah se maghfirat talab ki, Tashahhud padha, Hazrat Abu Bakr (R.A) ke haq ki tareef ki aur wazahat ki ke unhone jo kuch kiya woh na to Hazrat Abu Bakr se hasad ki wajah se tha aur na hi is wajah se ke Allah ne unhe fazilat di hai, balki woh samajhte thay ke is mamle (khilafat) mein unka bhi kuch haq hai.


Sunnah.com
Kya aap is hadith ka asli Arabic text dekhna chahenge, ya phir Fadak ke mamle par mukhtalif ulama ki tashreeh (explanation) samajhna chahenge?




Sahih al-Bukhari Hadith 4240 Islami tareekh (Islamic history) ke sabse ahem aur nazuk waqiat mein se ek ko bayan karti hai, jo Nabi Kareem (ﷺ) ki wafat ke baad pesh aaye.
Is hadith ki mukammal tashreeh (explanation) neeche diye gaye ahem nuqaat (key points) mein samjhi ja sakti hai:
1. Miras (Inheritance) aur Fadak ka Masla
Mutalba kya tha: Hazrat Fatima (R.A) ne apne walid Rasoolullah (ﷺ) ke baad unki chhori hui zameenon (jaise Fadak aur Khaibar ka hissa) mein se apni miras mangi, jaisa ke aam musalmano mein walid ke inteqal ke baad aulad ko hissa milta hai.
Hazrat Abu Bakr (R.A) ka jawab: Hazrat Abu Bakr (R.A) ne bataya ke unhone khud Nabi (ﷺ) se suna tha ke “Ambiya (Prophets) ka koi waris nahi hota; jo kuch woh chhorte hain woh Sadaqa (charity) hota hai.” Is liye woh zameen ab kisi ki zaati milkiyat nahi ban sakti thi, balki uski aamdani se Nabi (ﷺ) ke ghar walo (Aal-e-Muhammad) ke ikhrajat poore kiye jayenge aur baqi gareebon aur musalmano ki bhalai par kharch hoga—bilkul waise hi jaise Nabi (ﷺ) apni zindagi mein karte thay.
2. Hazrat Fatima (R.A) ki Narazgi ki Wajah
Ulama ke mutabiq, Hazrat Fatima (R.A) ko is hadees ka ilm nahi tha, is liye unhe laga ke shayad unhe unke haq se mehroom kiya ja raha hai.
Dusri taraf, Hazrat Abu Bakr (R.A) Nabi (ﷺ) ke hukm ke paband thay aur kisi ki khatir us mein tabdeeli nahi kar sakte thay.
Is ikhtilaf ki wajah se Hazrat Fatima (R.A) ne is mamle par dubara baat nahi ki aur apni wafat (jo 6 mahine baad hui) tak khamoshi ikhtiyar ki. Sunni ulama wazeh karte hain ke yeh narazgi kisi dushmani ya duniyawi lalach ki wajah se nahi thi, balki ek ijtihadi aur jazbati mamla tha.
3. Raat mein Dafan aur Hazrat Ali (R.A) ki Bai’at mein Takheer
Raat ka dafan: Hazrat Fatima (R.A) ne parde aur haya ki wajah se wasiyat ki thi ke unhe raat ke andhere mein dafan kiya jaye. Hazrat Ali (R.A) unki beemari aur timardari mein masroof thay, is liye unhone khud hi janaza padhaya aur dafan kar diya, aur khalifa ko ittila dene ki zaroorat mehsoos nahi ki.
Bai’at mein takheer: Nabi (ﷺ) ki wafat ke baad Saqifa Bani Sa’ida mein Hazrat Abu Bakr (R.A) ko jaldi mein khalifa chuna gaya tha taki ummat mein inteshar (fitna) na phaile. Hazrat Ali (R.A) is baat se thoda mutassir thay ke unhe is mashware mein shamil nahi kiya gaya, aur saath hi woh Hazrat Fatima (R.A) ki diljoee ke liye bhi unke saath rahe.
4. Sulah aur Public Bai’at (Reconciliation)
Jab Hazrat Fatima (R.A) ka inteqal ho gaya, to Hazrat Ali (R.A) ne mehsoos kiya ke unka khalifa se alag rehna musalmano mein galatfehmi paida kar sakta hai.
Unhone Hazrat Abu Bakr (R.A) ko apne ghar bulaya aur safai di ke unhe Hazrat Abu Bakr ki fazilat ya khilafat se koi hasad nahi hai, bas mashware mein shamil na kiye jaane ka gila tha.
Hazrat Abu Bakr (R.A) ro pade aur yaqeen dilaya ke Nabi (ﷺ) ke ghar walo ka khayal rakhna unhe apne rishtedaron se bhi zyada azeez hai.
Usi din Zuhr ki namaz ke baad masjid mein sab ke samne Hazrat Ali (R.A) ne Hazrat Abu Bakr (R.A) ke haath par bai’at (allegiance) kar li aur dono ke darmiyan mamla bilkul saaf ho gaya.
5. Mukhtalif Nazariyat (Sunni vs. Shia Perspective)
Sunni Nuqta-e-Nazar: Is hadith ko bilkul sahih maana jata hai. Is se sabit hota hai ke Sahaba ke darmiyan ikhtilaf ke bawajood unke dil ek dusre ke liye saaf thay, aur aakhirkar Hazrat Ali (R.A) ne khushi se Hazrat Abu Bakr (R.A) ki khilafat ko qubool kiya.
Shia Nuqta-e-Nazar: Shia riwayat ke mutabiq, Fadak Nabi (ﷺ) ne apni zindagi mein hi Hazrat Fatima (R.A) ko hiba (gift) kar diya tha, is liye woh miras nahi balki unki zaati milkiyat thi. Iske alawa, woh is hadith ke aakhri hisse (jisme Hazrat Ali ki raza-mandi se bai’at ka zikr hai) ko apni tareekhi riwayat ke khilaf maante hain.
Kya aap is waqie se judi doosri sahih ahadees (jaise Sahih Muslim ki riwayat) ke bare mein jaanna chahenge, ya Fadak ki zameen ka baad mein kya hua uski tareekh samajhna chahenge?




Is waqie se judi doosri sahih ahadees aur Fadak ki zameen ki aage ki tareekh Roman English mein neeche bayan ki gayi hai:
1. Doosri Sahih Ahadees (Related Narrations)
Sahih Muslim (Hadith 1759a): Yeh hadith bhi Hazrat Aisha (R.A) se riwayat hai aur bilkul wahi waqia bayan karti hai jo Sahih al-Bukhari 4240 mein hai. Ismein bhi zikr hai ke Hazrat Abu Bakr (R.A) ne Nabi (ﷺ) ka farman (“Hum Ambiya ki miras nahi hoti, jo hum chhorte hain woh sadaqa hai”) sunaya, aur Hazrat Fatima (R.A) ki wafat ke baad Hazrat Ali (R.A) ne Zuhr ke baad public bai’at ki. Aap poora text Sunnah.com par Sahih Muslim 1759a mein dekh sakte hain.


Sunnah.com
Sahih al-Bukhari (Hadith 3714): Is riwayat mein Rasoolullah (ﷺ) ka mashhoor farman darj hai: “Fatima mere jism ka tukda hai, jisne unhe naraz kiya usne mujhe naraz kiya.” Is hadith ka hawala aksar is bahas mein diya jata hai.


Facebook
Sahih al-Bukhari (Hadith 3093): Is mein zikr hai ke baad mein Hazrat Umar (R.A) ke daur-e-khilafat mein Hazrat Ali (R.A) aur Hazrat Abbas (R.A) ne is zameen ke intezam (management) ke mutalliq baat ki thi, aur Hazrat Umar (R.A) ne bhi usi usool ko barqarar rakha jo Nabi (ﷺ) aur Hazrat Abu Bakr (R.A) ke zamane mein tha.


Mahajjah
2. Fadak ki Zameen ka Baad mein Kya Hua? (Historical Timeline)
Fadak Madina se taqreeban 140–200 km door ek zarkhez (fertile) khajooron ka bagh tha. Khulafa-e-Rashideen aur baad ki hukoomaton mein iski haalat mukhtalif rahi:


Wikipedia
+1
Khulafa-e-Rashideen ka Daur:
Hazrat Abu Bakr aur Hazrat Umar (R.A): Dono khulafa ne Fadak ko Sadaqa / Fai (state trust) ke taur par rakha. Iski aamdani se Nabi (ﷺ) ke ghar walo (Ahl-e-Bayt) ke ikhrajat poore kiye jaate thay aur baqi musalmano ki falah par kharch hota tha.
Hazrat Uthman (R.A): Tareekhi riwayat ke mutabiq, unhone iske intezam ya hisse ko apne rishtedar Marwan bin Hakam ke supurd kar diya tha.
Hazrat Ali (R.A): Jab Hazrat Ali (R.A) khalifa bane, to unhone Fadak ko wapas liya, lekin unhone bhi usay zaati jaidad banane ke bajaye usi tareeqe se chalaya jaisa ke pehle ke khulafa (Abu Bakr aur Umar R.A) chalate aaye thay.
Umayyad aur Abbasid Daur:
Baad ke daur mein Fadak ek siyasi masla ban gaya aur hukmaranon ke sath iski malikiyat badalti rahi.
Umayyad khalifa Umar bin Abdul Aziz (R.A) ne apni khilafat ke dauran Fadak ko wapas Hazrat Fatima (R.A) ki aulad (Ahl-e-Bayt) ke hawale kar diya tha.
Isi tarah Abbasid khalifa Al-Ma’mun ne bhi isay Ahl-e-Bayt ko wapas kiya, jabki kayi doosre hukmaranon (jaise Muawiyah, Al-Mansur, aur Al-Mutawakkil) ne isay dobara hukoomat ke qabze mein le liya.


Al-Islam.org
+2
Kya aap Khutba-e-Fadak (jo Hazrat Fatima R.A ne masjid mein diya tha) ke bare mein jaanna chahenge, ya Fai aur Ghanimat ke Islami qanoon ko samajhna chahenge?
AI responses may include mistakes. For financial advice, consult a professional. Learn more




Khutba-e-Fadak aur Fai aur Ghanimat ke Islami qanoon ki mukammal maloomat Roman English mein neeche di gayi hai:
1. Khutba-e-Fadak (Sermon of Fadak)
Yeh kya hai: Tareekh aur khaas taur par Shia aur kuch Sunni tareekhi kitabon (jaise Balaghat al-Nisa by Ibn Abi Tayfur) ke mutabiq, jab Hazrat Fatima (R.A) ko Fadak ke mutalbe par inkar hua, to woh Masjid-e-Nabawi mein tashreef layin aur Muhajireen aur Ansar ke samne ek nihayat fasih-o-baligh (eloquent) khutba diya.
Khutbe ke Ahem Nuqaat:
Tauheed aur Risalat: Unhone Allah ki hamd aur apne walid Rasoolullah (ﷺ) ki kurbaniyon aur Islam ki khidmat ko yaad dilaya.
Quran se Dalail: Unhone Quran ki aayat (jaise Surah An-Naml 27:16 “Aur Sulaiman Dawood ke waris hue” aur Surah Maryam 19:5-6) ka hawala dekar apna muqaddama pesh kiya ke Ambiya ki miras hoti hai.
Ahl-e-Bayt ka Haq: Unhone musalmano ko unke ehsaanat yaad dilaye aur shikwa kiya ke Nabi (ﷺ) ki wafat ke itni jaldi baad unke ghar walo ke huqooq ko nazarandaz kiya ja raha hai.
Ulama ka Nazariya: Shia riwayat mein is khutbe ko ek buniyadi tareekhi dastavez maana jata hai. Jabki Sunni ulama is khutbe ki sanad (chain of narration) par tehqeeq karte hain aur kehte hain ke Quran mein Sulaiman (A.S) ki miras se murad ilm aur nabuwat ki miras hai, na ke maal-o-daulat, kyunki Nabi (ﷺ) ka apna farman (“Hum Ambiya ki miras nahi hoti”) zyada wazeh aur sahih sanad se sabit hai.
2. Fai aur Ghanimat ke Islami Qanoon
Hadith 4240 mein Fai aur Khumus ke alfaaz aaye hain. Islam mein jangi ya hukoomati maal ki do badi qismein hain:
Pehlu (Aspect) Maal-e-Ghanimat (War Booty) Maal-e-Fai
Tareef (Definition) Woh maal jo baqaida jung aur ladaai ke baad dushman se haasil ho. Woh maal jo baghair jung aur khoon-kharabe ke sulah ya dushman ke bhag jaane se haasil ho (jaise Fadak).
Taqseem ka Qanoon 4 hisse (80%) jung mein hissa lene wale mujahideen mein taqseem hote hain. Baqi 1 hissa (20%) ko Khumus kehte hain. Yeh poora ka poora maal Bait-ul-Maal (Islamic State) aur Rasoolullah (ﷺ) ke ikhtiyar mein hota hai; is mein mujahideen ka hissa nahi hota.
Kharch karne ki Jagah Khumus (20%) Allah aur Rasool (ﷺ), unke rishtedaron (Banu Hashim/Banu Muttalib), yateemon, miskeeno aur musafiron par kharch hota hai (Surah Al-Anfal 8:41). Yeh poora maal Nabi (ﷺ) ke ghar walo ki zarooriyat aur aam musalmano ki falah-o-behbood, difa (defense) aur gareebon par kharch hota hai (Surah Al-Hashr 59:6-7).
Fadak ka Ta’alluq: Kyunki Fadak ke logon ne baghair jung kiye Rasoolullah (ﷺ) se sulah kar li thi, is liye Fadak Maal-e-Fai tha. Isi wajah se is par kisi mujahid ka haq nahi tha aur iska intezam seedha Rasoolullah (ﷺ) ke paas tha.
Kya aap Khulafa-e-Rashideen ke daur mein Bait-ul-Maal ke nizam ko samajhna chahenge, ya kisi doosri hadith par baat karna chahenge?
AI responses may include mistakes. For financial advice, consult a professional. Learn more




AI Mode response is ready